mihom
searchexploreopen housesmarket
Saved
mihom

find your home. homes for sale across Canada, with real prices and every neighbourhood in one place.

  • search homes
  • map search
  • browse by area
  • your saved homes
  • homes by city
  • BC housing market
  • what's my home worth?
  • buying an older condo
homes for sale by city
  • Vancouver homes for sale
  • Surrey homes for sale
  • Kelowna homes for sale
  • Richmond homes for sale
  • Burnaby homes for sale
  • Langley homes for sale
  • Coquitlam homes for sale
  • Abbotsford homes for sale
  • Chilliwack homes for sale
  • Kamloops homes for sale
  • North Vancouver homes for sale
  • Maple Ridge homes for sale
  • Prince George homes for sale
  • Nanaimo homes for sale
  • Vernon homes for sale
  • Delta homes for sale
  • West Kelowna homes for sale
  • Victoria homes for sale
  • New Westminster homes for sale
  • Langford homes for sale
  • Mission homes for sale
  • Saanich homes for sale
  • West Vancouver homes for sale
  • Penticton homes for sale
  • Port Coquitlam homes for sale
  • Osoyoos homes for sale
  • White Rock homes for sale
  • Campbell River homes for sale
  • Whistler homes for sale
  • Port Moody homes for sale
popular neighbourhoods
  • Lower Mission, Kelowna
  • Kelowna North, Kelowna
  • Westbank Centre, West Kelowna
  • Kelowna South, Kelowna
  • Main North, Penticton
  • Downtown, Victoria
  • Bear Mountain, Langford
  • Rutland North, Kelowna
  • North Nanaimo, Nanaimo
  • Lakeview Heights, West Kelowna
  • East Duncan, Duncan
  • Lake Country South West, Lake Country
  • Main South, Penticton
  • Springfield/Spall, Kelowna
  • Glenmore, Kelowna
  • Campbell River Central, Campbell River
  • NE Salmon Arm, Salmon Arm
  • Willow Point, Campbell River
  • South Kamloops, Kamloops
  • Brocklehurst, Kamloops
  • West Duncan, Duncan
  • Shannon Lake, West Kelowna
  • Okanagan Landing, Vernon
  • City of Vernon, Vernon
by property type
  • condos in Vancouver
  • houses in Vancouver
  • townhouses in Vancouver
  • houses in Surrey
  • condos in Surrey
  • townhouses in Surrey
  • houses in Kelowna
  • condos in Kelowna
  • townhouses in Kelowna
  • condos in Richmond
  • houses in Richmond
  • townhouses in Richmond
  • condos in Burnaby
  • houses in Burnaby
  • townhouses in Burnaby
by price
  • Vancouver homes under $500K
  • Vancouver homes under $1M
  • Vancouver homes under $2M
  • Vancouver homes over $2M
Alberta
  • all Alberta homes
  • Calgary homes for sale
  • Edmonton homes for sale
  • Lethbridge homes for sale
  • Airdrie homes for sale
  • Red Deer homes for sale
  • Cochrane homes for sale
  • Grande Prairie homes for sale
  • Spruce Grove homes for sale
  • Chestermere homes for sale
  • Rural Rocky View County homes for sale
  • Leduc homes for sale
  • Fort McMurray homes for sale
  • Camrose homes for sale
  • Rural Parkland County homes for sale
  • St. Albert homes for sale
  • Sherwood Park homes for sale
  • Medicine Hat homes for sale
  • Rural Grande Prairie No. 1, County of homes for sale
  • Sylvan Lake homes for sale
  • Fort Saskatchewan homes for sale
Pemberton Holmes Ltd.

mihom.ca is operated by Dan Robbins, REALTOR®, Pemberton Holmes Ltd.

REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are certification marks that are owned by REALTOR® Canada Inc. and licensed exclusively to The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA). These certification marks identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA and who must abide by CREA's By-Laws, Rules, and the REALTOR® Code. The MLS® trademark and the MLS® logo are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Listing data via CREA's DDF®. about · terms of use · privacy · © 2026 mihom.

58 Methodist Island
homes for sale · Tay · Port McNicoll
58 Methodist Island — photo 1 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 2 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 3 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 4 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 5 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 6 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 7 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 8 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 9 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 10 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 11 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 12 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 13 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 14 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 15 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 16 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 17 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 18 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 19 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 20 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 21 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 22 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 23 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 24 of 25
58 Methodist Island — photo 25 of 25
1 / 25
$899,900

58 Methodist Island

Port McNicoll, Tay · MLS® S13588020

32

House · Single Family · 95 days on market

listed by TIM HEWITT, CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.

realtor's description

A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighbors as you cruise by. The 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage has been completely gutted and transformed into a turnkey high end property. New flooring, new kitchen, new appliances, new furniture, new bathrooms and pot lights throughout. With the bonus of a Muskoka room for extra sleeping quarters or peaceful retreat. This cottage can sleep up to 10 people comfortably. The hot tub extends your days outdoors into the evenings with sounds of laughter and joy from the kids. Inside turn on Netflix and watch movies on the 75 big screen. High speed internet when working remotely is top notch. This is more than a cottage, its a lifestyle!

property details

type
House, Single Family
bedrooms
3
bathrooms
2
parking
0
property tax
$3,669 / yr
days on market
95
MLS®
S13588020

features

  • Carpet Free
  • Washer
  • Refrigerator
  • Oven
  • Dryer
  • Cooktop

monthly cost

$4,227/mo
Mortgage $3,921 · Tax $306

20% down at 4.34% fixed (Ratehub.ca), 25 years; tax from the listing.

estimated payment
$3,921/ monthly
loan $719,920
25-year amortization
total interest
$456,313
cash to close
$179,980
down payment; transfer tax and fees not included
total paid
$1,176,233

Estimates only. Rates change daily and lenders qualify at the stress-test rate. Talk to a mortgage broker before you offer.

Keep private notes and ratings on homes you're considering. (email only) and they follow you to every device.

listed by
TIM HEWITT
CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
call TIM · 705-721-9111
Powered by: REALTOR.ca
▶ virtual tour

similar homes nearby

location

Port McNicoll, TayGoogle Maps ↗

location

Port McNicoll, TayGoogle Maps ↗
0

Walkability 0/100 · Car needed for most errands

Nothing everyday within a 10 minute walk.

mihom score from OpenStreetMap places, by straight line distance.

753 Fifth Avenue, Tay
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, photo 2
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, photo 3
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, photo 4
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, photo 5
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, photo 6
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, photo 7
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, photo 8
House
$679,000
4methe deep dive
753 Fifth Avenue
Port McNicoll, Tay8 days on market
listed by HOME CHOICE REALTY INC.
334
MLS® S14089526
480 Broderick Street, Tay
480 Broderick Street, Tay, photo 2
480 Broderick Street, Tay, photo 3
480 Broderick Street, Tay, photo 4
480 Broderick Street, Tay, photo 5
480 Broderick Street, Tay, photo 6
480 Broderick Street, Tay, photo 7
480 Broderick Street, Tay, photo 8
House
$669,777
4methe deep dive
480 Broderick Street
Port McNicoll, Tay10 days on market
listed by RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd
52
5 Easton Avenue, Tay
5 Easton Avenue, Tay, photo 2
5 Easton Avenue, Tay, photo 3
5 Easton Avenue, Tay, photo 4
5 Easton Avenue, Tay, photo 5
5 Easton Avenue, Tay, photo 6
5 Easton Avenue, Tay, photo 7
5 Easton Avenue, Tay, photo 8
House
$699,777
4methe deep dive
5 Easton Avenue
Port McNicoll, Tay23 days on market
listed by RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd
328
757 Fourth Avenue, Tay
757 Fourth Avenue, Tay, photo 2
757 Fourth Avenue, Tay, photo 3
757 Fourth Avenue, Tay, photo 4
757 Fourth Avenue, Tay, photo 5
757 Fourth Avenue, Tay, photo 6
757 Fourth Avenue, Tay, photo 7
757 Fourth Avenue, Tay, photo 8
House
$849,000
4methe deep dive
757 Fourth Avenue
Port McNicoll, Tay31 days on market
listed by CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
7410
528 First Avenue, Tay
528 First Avenue, Tay, photo 2
528 First Avenue, Tay, photo 3
528 First Avenue, Tay, photo 4
528 First Avenue, Tay, photo 5
528 First Avenue, Tay, photo 6
528 First Avenue, Tay, photo 7
528 First Avenue, Tay, photo 8
House
$649,999
4methe deep dive
528 First Avenue
Port McNicoll, Tay32 days on market
listed by CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
3215
40 - 76 Dock Lane, Tay
40 - 76 Dock Lane, Tay, photo 2
40 - 76 Dock Lane, Tay, photo 3
40 - 76 Dock Lane, Tay, photo 4
40 - 76 Dock Lane, Tay, photo 5
40 - 76 Dock Lane, Tay, photo 6
Land
$800,000
4methe deep dive
40 - 76 Dock Lane
Port McNicoll, Tay32 days on market
listed by CENTURY 21 PERCY FULTON LTD.
MLS® S13812908
6
MLS® S14032128
MLS® S13846968
MLS® S13821326
MLS® S13816372