Homes for sale in Port McNicoll, Tay

32 homes for sale in Port McNicoll, Tay, median asking $549,945 ($54,900 to $2,750,000). The typical home has been listed 47 days; 4 came on in the last 7 days. Houses make up 72% of what's for sale.

view 32 homes →
Port McNicoll has 32 homes currently for sale, with a median asking price of $549,945. Listings range from $54,900 to $2,750,000, and the median time on market is 47 days. Four homes were listed in the past week, and 12 in the past month. Most listings are houses, with a median price of $574,999, while land parcels make up the rest, with a median of $129,900. By bedroom count, one-bedroom homes are the most affordable, with a median of $129,900, while three-bedroom homes have the highest median at $749,389. The majority of listings—29—are priced under $1 million, with 13 of those under $500K. There are 30 homes listed under $2 million and two over that amount.

Summary written by mihom with AI, from the MLS® listing data on this page (October 25, 2026). The figures below are counted straight from the listings.

32
homes
$549,945
median asking
$55K to $2.75M
—
median per sq ft
47 days
median on market
4
listed this week
12 in 30 days
—
median year built

asking prices

13
11
5
1
2
<$500K
$500–750K
$750K–1M
$1–1.5M
$1.5–2M
$2–3M
$3M+

on the map

by type

typehomesmedian
houses23$574,999
Land9$129,900

by bedrooms

bedroomshomesmedian
1 bedroom9$129,900
3 bedroom8$749,389
4 bedroom5$549,900
5+ bedroom6$562,495

by price

pricehomesmedian
under $500K13—

questions buyers ask

What do homes in Port McNicoll, Tay cost?

Median asking price is $549,945 across 32 active listings, ranging from $54,900 to $2,750,000.

How fast are homes selling here?

The median active listing has been on the market 47 days. 4 homes were listed in the last week and 12 in the last 30 days.

How much more is a 3-bedroom than a 2-bedroom?

Median asking is $424,500 for 2 bedrooms (4 listings) and $749,389 for 3 bedrooms (8 listings).

What types of homes are for sale?

23 houses (median $574,999), 9 Land (median $129,900).

statistics are computed from the 32 active MLS® listings matching this page and refresh every few hours with the feed. medians, not averages, so one outlier can't move them.